Procter Insurance Agency - South Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Yatin P.

Chris and the team at Procter Insurance Agency have been helping our family with all our insurance needs for years, and I can't recommend them enough! I feel bad for not leaving a review sooner because they’ve truly been outstanding. Whether it’s auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life insurance, or renters insurance and more, Chris covers it all.

When we first found Chris, we spent time reviewing all of our policies, and it’s been a game-changer. Not only did he help us find the best coverage tailored to our needs, but he also saved us so much time and stress. He works with multiple providers, so he gives an honest, unbiased overview to help you meet your goals—whether you’re looking to save money or maximize coverage.

What stands out the most is the exceptional service. Anytime I have a question, I just send an email, and Chris and his team respond almost immediately—usually within an hour! I don’t have to waste time on hold with insurance companies. Chris should be THE trusted, local Milwaukee insurance expert for everyone if you ask me, and having someone like him to handle all our policies has been invaluable.

If you’re in the Milwaukee area and looking for a reliable, independent insurance agency, do yourself a favor and start with Chris at Procter Insurance. He’s knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely has your best interests at heart. His team is the best! Highly recommend! 10/10. Chris, keep it going!!!

Michael H.

My experience with Procter has been very positive, from getting quotes to support with claims. The responses have always been, prompt, courteous, and professional. Procter is the best insurance agency I've ever worked with.

Alyssa J.

Chris is a top-notch agent! He is always available to help and so knowledgeable. We love bringing our business to him.

BeatleBug69

I have worked with Procter for about 25 years for my auto and renters insurance needs. They are always very helpful and easy to work with, whether it's making a change to an existing policy or obtaining a new policy.

Randall T.

The agent followed up with me quickly on a quote for business and personal insurance. I had a bad experience with one of the companies Procter sells and the agent respected this. We made follow up plans on going with a different company Procter sells at a later date. The agent had good communication and was understanding of my previous experiences. This experience was positive, and I will be following up with them at a later date.

Kathy A.

We have had our home, cars and vacation home insured by Procter Ins. for 11 years and all I can say is Thank You to Chris and his staff. It's been a pleasure to work with him over the years. We feel that we have very good insurance with very fair rates.
His help with handling a claim has been excellent and his followup to any questions is always immediate. Highly recommend Procter for all your insurance needs!

Heydee V.

In the past when it came to searching for the right home and auto insurance I can honestly say it was a process that I dreaded and I wasn’t looking forward to have to do it again. I recently had to change insurance provider because my rates were going to double now that our oldest started to drive and had to be added to our policy. I decided to send a post on an Oak Creek parent’s page asking for suggestions for insurance agents. I was lucky that someone who read my post sent Chris my way and I couldn’t be happier. He took the time to answer all my questions and made the transition from our former agency to Procter Insurance very smooth. I am happy with my decision and recommend Chris to all my friends and family.

S P.

The Procter Agency is the best I have ever worked with. Especially Christopher is so nice and warm, and of course competent. I've tried lots of quotes from other insurance companies but he always offers the best price and options for insurance. At first, I was introduced through my car dealer, and now I am introducing my friends to this agency.