Catalli Insurance Brokers - San Mateo, California

Jessica F.

I can't say enough good things about Catalli Insurance Brokers and the exceptional service I received from Tony. After a frustrating experience elsewhere—where I was given no guidance and was simply told to "read the policy" myself—Tony was a breath of fresh air. From the moment we connected, he went above and beyond to ensure I understood every step of the process. His patience, expertise, and genuine commitment to helping me made all the difference. He didn’t just do the bare minimum—he made me feel like a valued client, not just another policyholder. If you're looking for an insurance broker who truly cares, I highly recommend Tony and Catalli Insurance Brokers.

Cheryl W.

During the recent insurance industry havoc, I was among the cancelled policy holders, with no satisfactory answers or assistance from my current broker. Three weeks later, 4 brokers, and hours of application submissions, I was frustrated and panicked. Then I found Tony Catalli. He was immediately responsive and knowledgeable. Three days later, I had clear candid answers, more professional advice, and a seamless application process. I am more confident than ever that Catalli is a full support agency that I will wholeheartedly recommend to friends and family. Thank you Tony!

Sean J.

Tony and his team have been very helpful in finding better insurance options when my previous provider raised the premiums considerably even though I had never filed a claim. He and his team were always responsive and following through when I needed to make changes as well. Highly recommended!

Sundar V.

I had the pleasure of working with Tony for my insurance needs, and I can’t recommend him enough! He helped me secure insurance for my cars, home, and even an umbrella policy. Tony did an outstanding job explaining all the products in detail, making the process easy to understand. He went above and beyond to find me the best discounts and ensure I got excellent rates.

What impressed me the most was how smooth the entire process was—Tony delivered exactly what he promised and made everything seamless from start to finish. His professionalism and attention to detail made it a true pleasure to work with him. If you’re looking for someone reliable, knowledgeable, and committed to getting you the best deal, Tony is the agent for you!

Let me know if you’d like to adjust it further!

Michael G.

When our previous insurance company was no longer writing policies in California for umbrella liability coverage, we were very concerned. A close friend recommended that I contact Tony at Catalli Insurance Brokers. Within a week we went from very concerned about our insurance coverage to so relieved thanks to new policies with Mercury Insurance which Tony found for us. We got better coverage for auto, home and umbrella coverage with just a minimal increase in price. And their service was fantastic! We'd highly recommend them.

Asia Q.

Our experience with Tony has been nothing short of outstanding. He is always extremely helpful and timely, responding to our needs with great professionalism. He and his team have been amazing to work with, consistently going above and beyond to ensure we have the best possible coverage.

We had a hard time finding a reasonable home insurance price from a reputable company, but he stepped in and found us a fantastic option. No matter what questions we have, he is always quick to assist, making sure we understand our options and working hard to get us the best deals. We couldn’t be happier with Tony and his team!

Joan H.

I had no idea how much trouble I could have been in if I had a need for the services of my last insurer. After 20 YEARS of paying premiums and never placing a claim, I received a letter from my insurer canceling my policy and a picture by a Drone and an arrow pointing to a large dark area on the roof and claiming I had "MOLD"
I hired a roofer and someone to take pictures to respond to this charge. The dark area was a shadow of a tree!?! They responded to this information by telling me I had to take pictures from every corner of my roof. I contacted Tony and his response was awesome. Reviewed all my policies and offered me better policies for less and now have the security of having someone I can rely on should I need to make a claim for help.

andres U.

Tony was fantastic in helping me set up my Auto, Renters, and Umbrella insurance policies. He made the whole process smooth and stress-free, finding the best options tailored to my needs. His knowledge, professionalism, and prompt responses made working with him a pleasure. I highly recommend!